Machida Vs Shogun: One Judge Speaks Out On His Controversial Scorecard

Saturday night saw one of the UFC’s most controversial decisions ever as Lyoto Machida won a unanimous decision to retain his light heavweight title, despite the vast majority of people watching being convinced that Mauricio ‘Shogun’ Rua had done enough to take the victory.

Now, one of the three judges who scored the bout in favor of Lyoto ‘The Dragon’ Machida has spoken out on his decision. Cecil Peoples, who gave Machida rounds 1, 2 & 3, had the following to say when he spoke to

“First of all what you need to understand is that from where the judges are sitting, we get to see things that the fans at home may miss. Mauricio Rua was being aggressive but it wasn’t effective aggressiveness which is what we as the judges look for when scoring a fight. The way I saw it, Lyoto was landing the more cleaner and damaging strikes throughout the fight – if you take a look at the judging criteria clean strikes are valued more-so than the quantity of strikes landed. Although Rua threw a lot of low kicks they were not as damaging as Lyotos diverse attack in the earlier rounds which is why I scored the first three rounds for Machida. You have to keep in mind we always the favour the fighter who is trying to finish the fight, and leg kicks certainly don’t do that.”

“When both fighters are engaged in a striking match what I always look for is the fighter who is being judicious, picking his spots, being accurate and landing the cleaner strikes which ultimately is what Lyoto did more effectively than Rua. Lyoto made Shogun come after him, he determined where the fight took place which in my opinion constitutes as effective Octagon control. I recognize the fact that Rua did have a few takedown attempts during the course of the fight however Lyoto defended them all successfully which counts as effective grappling in his favour, where as ununsuccessful takedown attempts are not scored at all. Therefore going by that criteria, I believe Lyoto won the fight clearly. I’m just glad the other judges on the panel saw it the same way and I’m sure the fans who understand the technicalities of the sport agree with the decision too.”


  1. I think Cecil Peoples should be banded from Judging… Those that didn’t know he was also oneof the judes for the TUF tonight. I seen TUF tonight and couldn’t beleive that the fight didn’t go to the 3rd round. He gave both rounds to Matt Mitrione over Scott Junk. There’s no way Matt won that 2nd round. He truly has lost it.

  2. Cecil Peoples does seem to have a knack for coming up with curious decisions. He’s been doing it for years though, so I doubt he’s going to stop now!

    I was disappointed in the TUF fight. Junk’s comeback after looking beaten early in the first was entertaining to watch, but the technique and endurance on display by both fighters was woeful. It’s something that appears to be a feature of this season unfortunately.

    Other than the fight I thought it was a fun episode though.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here