Boxing legend and Golden Boy promoter Oscar De La Hoya has written an open letter to boxing fans to warn them that a mega-fight between Floyd Mayweather Jr and Conor McGregor has the potential to bad for the boxing business in the longer term.
De La Hoya argues that though the sport is currently on the rise after a series of hugely successful fights in the year so far, an overly-expensive, one-sided, anti-climatic fight between the best boxer of his generation and an MMA fighter with no prior experience in the squared circle could deal the credibility of boxing a damaging blow that it may not recover from.
Read De La Hoya’s full statement below.
“To my fellow #boxing fans:
I write in the hopes that together we can protect the sport of boxing.
With each passing day, it looks more and more likely that the circus known as Floyd Mayweather Vs. Conor McGregor will be coming to town in the near future.
As undercard fights start to take form, athletic commissions give their blessings in exchange for millions of dollars and the fighters start counting even more cash, one group will eventually be left to make sure this farce doesn’t occur.
We, the fans, who are the lifeblood of our sport.
Boxing is starting to dig out of the hole that Floyd and Manny Pacquiao shoveled by waiting seven years to put on a fight that ended up being as dull as it was anti-climactic.
2017 has started off as a banner year for boxing. Joshua vs. Klitschko; Thurman vs. Garcia; Golovkin vs. Jacobs; Canelo vs. Chavez. All four of these fights – and many more — have brought the fight game back and reinvigorated interest from the ever-elusive casual fan.
But if you thought Mayweather/Pacquiao was a black eye for our sport – a matchup between two of the best pound-for-pound fighters that simply didn’t deliver — just wait until the best boxer of a generation dismantles someone who has never boxed competitively at any level – amateur or professional.
Our sport might not ever recover.
I fully understand the initial attraction from any fan of combat sports. McGregor is almost certainly the best pound-for-pound MMA fighter. Floyd is Floyd — the most dominant boxer of his time.
But success in one sport does not guarantee success in another. Far from it. And let’s be clear, these are two different sports — from the size of the gloves fighters wear, to the size and shape of the ring, to the fact the one sport allows combatants to use their legs to strike.
Think about it, beyond Bo Jackson and Deion Sanders, what other athlete has successfully competed in two sports in the modern age? And Jackson and Sanders both played both baseball and football throughout their high school and college careers before going professional.
Furthermore, it’s not like McGregor would be fighting a good fighter, let alone a mediocre one. He would be fighting the best. To use a bit of an extreme analogy, I happen to be a pretty good golfer. Could I potentially hold my own on one of the second-tier tours? Maybe. But would I be able to compete with Rory McIlroy, Jordan Speith or Sergio Garcia? Of course not. Nor would I think to try.
Now, I know critics will say that I’m only writing this letter because my company is promoting what will be the culmination of an outstanding boxing year when Canelo Alvarez takes on Gennady “GGG” Golovkin in September, and I don’t want anything to distract attention away from that fight.
But my interest is in the health of boxing as a whole. It always has been. And if Floyd were to come out of retirement to take on someone like Keith “One–time” Thurman, Errol Spence or some other top welterweight, not only would I applaud the fight, I’d be the first one on line for a ticket.
That kind of fight is what the fans – and I am a fan first — deserve.
Which brings me back to the circus.
Floyd’s and Conor’s motivation is clear. It’s money. In fact, they don’t even pretend it’s not. But it’s also a lack of consequences for when the fight ends up being the disaster that is predicted. After this fight, neither of them will need us anymore. Floyd will go back to retirement — presumably for good this time with another nine-figure paycheck — and Conor will go back to the UFC.
It’s a win-win for them. It’s a lose-lose for us. We’ll be $100 lighter and we will have squandered another opportunity to bring boxing back to its rightful place as the sport of kings.
At this point, only we can shut the circus down by making it clear that we won’t pay to see a joke of a fight and telling our casual-fan friends that they shouldn’t either.
It’s interesting to see a superstar boxer take this stance given that it’s generally believed that it’s the sport of MMA and the UFC brand that has a much bigger risk of looking bad if this fight does go ahead.
His argument seems a bit over the top though. It’s quite likely that the fight is anti-climatic, but it’s more likely to result in a backlash against future circus-style crossover fights between the two sports, but it’s doubtful it would dampen people’s enthusiasm to watch the likes of Anthony Joshua and Canelo Alvarez compete.
That being said, there are risks for boxing that De La Hoya doesn’t mention. the 1 in a 100 chance that McGregor is somehow able to find the 40-year-old Mayweather’s chin and stops him would be a disaster for the sport.
A scenario that has a better chance of becoming a reality is that McGregor is able to survive the full 12 rounds and is never put in any real danger, in which case he would be able to claim a moral victory.
Whatever the outcome, the truth of the matter is that no-one is going to be successfully able to convince fans that they shouldn’t watch the fight.
For better or worse, the momentum that’s gathered behind this match-up has already become too powerful to stop.